Zoom Link to the Forum https://bit.ly/gta-may
Category: Uncategorized
Questions from Membership Meeting
Please see GTA responses to the remaining questions that we did not have the time to address at the membership meeting.
Question:
Is it possible to convince mgmt. of the necessity to post the numbers of our buildings on or closer to South End Ave? Taxis, deliveries, visitors spend untold hours going up and down looking for us.
GTA Response:
We will bring this up with management at our next meeting. Thank you for the suggestion.
Question:
My questions were about gateway staff over an elevator leaving us with 2 instead of 4. Can they do work during non-work hours and if you asked them, what did they say?
GTA Response:
We have discussed this with. Management. They do attempt to do this but are not always successful. They told us that they now throw recycling down the shoot, and it is divided at the bottom. Also, they are not picking up as often as before. We will raise it again with management at our next meeting.
Question:
Can someone please address why mgmt. will not be more proactive with managing the elevator disruptions? Namely publish the schedule for when an elevator is out of service for recycling pickups, moving in or out. Many tenants can be flexible when they dog walk or do laundry and would do so if they knew an additional elevator was out of service. Can recycle pick-ups be limited to no more than 30 min per session.
GTA Response:
We have discussed this with management and have asked that notification be sent to affected residents. They were not agreeable to this suggestion but will raise it again.
Question:
I am not sure if this has been brought up before. Does anyone have any information about the lovely dumpster that has been sitting in the ring road for the last 5 years at least? I have reached out to mgmt., and they only advise that I should email Tuminia. He does not respond. It’s unsightly and smells during the summer.
GTA Response:
We will discuss it with management at our next meeting and report back.
Question:
What is the plan for elevator upgrades in buildings with only one elevator?
GTA Response:
We asked last time but they were not sure yet. According to Greg email on Feb 22nd, below was his report
Low Rise Elevators – The low-rise elevators modernization project is scheduled for the spring of 2025. We are finalizing details with the elevator contractor to confirm how long the 345, 265 & 385 elevators will be out of service. With each of these buildings having only one elevator we want to be completely transparent with all residents as to the time frame these buildings will be without an elevator. There may be an option to reduce the work schedule from 15 weeks to 8 weeks. Once we receive the final scope of work, we will begin to contact every resident in 345, 365 & 385 to accommodate their needs accordingly.
Question:
During your next session with mgmt. Discussing security, please inquire about getting cameras in the stairwells.
GTA Response:
We have requested cameras in stairwells, but they were not agreeable to this suggestion.
Question:
Can someone address the cost of utilities?
GTA Response:
The electric bills at Gateway are so high primarily because tenants pay for their own heat (electric) in the winter and air conditioning in the summer; in many residential buildings, heat is supplied by the landlord and included in the rent. Gateway buys electricity and then submeters it to the tenants. Your electric bill will include the number of kilowatt-hours consumed and the per-kilowatt-hour price being charged. Under an agreement that Gateway has with the Battery Park City Authority, Gateway is not permitted to make a profit on submetering electricity to tenants, and the BPCA performs audits annually to make sure Gateway adheres to that agreement.
ConEd provides a portal on its website where you can compare your actual Gateway electrical bill with what the same amount of electricity would have cost you if you bought it directly from ConEd. That web portal is:
Although the GTA Board has not done a scientific sampling of tenants’ electric bills versus the ConEd portal, we have done spot-checks, and those spot-checks have shown that the Gateway bills were less than what it would have cost to have bought the electricity directly from ConEd.
Question:
I was told I cannot opt out of the health club. How can I?
GTA Response:
If you are a market tenant, you can’t. We have mentioned this in many of our meetings and they are not willing to waive the fee for market rate tenants. They charge this fee as part of the Amenities rider and it is for use of health club, 4th floor roof deck, Business center and north lawn. If you are QRS, you only pay if you choose to use the health club. When the Amenities Rider first appeared, GTA raised objections to this Amenities rider with Greg Tumminia (Gateway General Manager). Although he defended the Amenities rider as consistent with market for the market rate tenants, GTA continues to believe that this Amenities rider is inappropriate for all tenants, including market rate tenants, and is advocating for removal of this rider for all residents.
ANNUAL MEETING and BOARD ELECTIONS
GATEWAY TENANTS ASSOCIATION
ANNUAL MEETING and BOARD ELECTIONS
FEBRUARY 29, 7 PM
Via Zoom
Click here to join meeting: GTA Meeting Link Webinar ID: 815 5608 0276
The Gateway Tenants Association will be hosting our annual meeting via Zoom on Thur., Feb 29th at 7pm. We will be joined by elected officials and guests who will talk about issues that affect Gateway. Scheduled to attend: Congressman Daniel Goldman, State Senator Brian Kavanaugh, State Assemblyman Charles Fall, Council Member Christopher Marte, Battery Park City Authority President and Chief Executive Officer, Raju Mann.
At this meeting, the election of the next GTA Board will take place.
MARKET RATE REPRESENTATION NEEDED ON THE GTA BOARD
WE ENCOURAGE COMMUNITY MINDED RESIDENTS WHO WANT TO ADDRESS THE ISSUES THAT CONCERNS THEM TO RUN FOR THE BOARD.
If you want to put your name on the ballot, please provide a paragraph on why you want to serve and send it to gatewayplazata@gmail.cm by February 26th. A list of the candidates will be sent before the meeting but we will accept nominations at the meeting as well.
Updates from the GTA Board will be presented followed by a Q and A. If you have any questions and would like to submit beforehand, send to gatewayplazata@gmail.com
THERE IS POWER IN NUMBERS
PLEASE JOIN OR RENEW YOUR GTA MEMBERSHIP
We invite all Gateway resident to join GTA. Our very existence depends upon the participation of the tenant population.
The larger our membership, the greater our power and influence.
Let your voice be heard and join others toward the betterment of our community!
Dues are just $25 per household per calendar year so join NOW. You have to be a member to vote.
Click here to JOIN NOW!
MARKET RENT SURVEY
MARKET RENT SURVEY
(previously reported in January newsletter)
During fall 2023, GTA conducted a survey of tenants’ experiences with renewal lease rent increases, focusing on the body of tenants who are not covered by the Quasi Rent Stabilization (QRS) Agreement. We received 171 responses. To place rent increases in the context of the overall economy, the annual rate of inflation for 2023, as measured by the Urban Consumer Price Index, was 4.1%.
Over three-quarters of the rent increases stated in tenants’ renewal offers were greater than the rate of inflation – specifically, 77% of survey respondents’ renewal offers were greater than 5%. Most renewal offers were substantially greater than the rate of inflation, as summarized in the following table:
Share of Respondents Renewal offer increase amount
77% greater than 5%
65% greater than 10%
47% greater than 15%
32% greater than 20%
On the good news side of things, tenants who tried to negotiate renewal increases were often successful in achieving lower increases, sometimes significantly lower. Roughly two-thirds of respondents reported that they tried to negotiate renewal rents, and of those, roughly half reported being successful in achieving a renewal rent lower than what had been proposed by management.
Lessons that can be drawn from the survey include:
Don’t just accept the renewal rent increase contained in your lease renewal offer – try to negotiate. One successful negotiation approach has been to present management with evidence that similar apartments are being offered at rates lower than what is being requested of the tenant at renewal. You can see what Gateway is currently offering for rent at its website, gatewayny.com.
In the absence of legal or contractual limits on renewal rent increases, tenants are at the mercy of unpredictable market forces that take little account of how long a tenant has made an apartment their home or how timely the tenant has been in rent payment. If the landlord believes a new tenant would pay 20% or more in rent than a current tenant is paying, the landlord is likely to demand a 20% or higher rent increase at lease renewal.
The renewal rent increase experience of Gateway tenants demonstrates the importance of enacting Good Cause Eviction legislation that has been repeatedly introduced in the New York Legislature, but which has not passed. This legislation would limit rent increases to an amount tied to the rate of inflation. For example, NYS Senate bill S3082 introduced in the 2021-2022 Session would limit rent increases to the greater of 3% or 1.5 times the rate of inflation. If you believe these protections are important, please contact our State Senator, Brian Kavanagh (https://www.nysenate.gov/senators/brian-kavanagh), our Assembly Member, Charles Fall (https://nyassembly.gov/mem/Charles-D-Fall) and Governor Kathy Hochul (https://www.governor.ny.gov), and urge them to enact Good Cause Eviction legislation.
UNOFFICIAL NAME CHANGE
Since the complex is now known as “Gateway” rather than “Gateway Plaza,” we are calling the organization” Gateway Tenants Association” or “GTA”.
Our contact information and social media will remain the same.
The website will continue as gpta.org,
The email address as gatewayplazata@gmail.com.
The Twitter handle will remain @GPTA_BPC and Facebook as Gateway Plaza Tenants Association.
Building Community
Our mission
To work together to build and maintain a high quality of life in our community in every possible way for the tenants of Gateway Plaza.
Our history
The Gateway Plaza Tenants Association was created in 1982 to respond to tenant-related issues at Gateway Plaza, the largest residential complex in Battery Park City. Over the last three decades, GPTA has accomplished a variety of goals, including negotiating long-term rent-stabilization agreements with the landlord, thereby preserving Gateway as a family-friendly residential community for people with diverse incomes.
Join Us
There is Power in Numbers! Please Join or Renew Your GTA Membership Today!
We invite all Gateway resident to join GTA. Our very existence depends upon the participation of the tenant population.
The larger our membership, the greater our power and influence.
Let your voice be heard and join others toward the betterment of our community!
Dues for membership are a true bargain — just $25 per household per calendar year. We appreciate your support!
STAY CONNECTED
Website: gpta.org
Email: GatewayPlazaTA@gmail.com
Address: GPTA, PO Box 3266, Church St. Station, New York, NY 10008
Twitter: @GPTA_BPC
Facebook: Gateway Plaza Tenants Association
GPTA BOARD OF DIRECTORS
President- Rosalie Joseph
1st Vice President- Robin Forst
2nd Vice President- Vittoria Fariello
Secretary- Jeff Galloway
Treasurer- Karlene Weiss
Board of Directors:
Sarah Cassell
Audrey Comisky
Larry Emert
Pat Gray
Howard Grossman
Steve Kessler
Shannon McCue
Notice
The Gateway Plaza Tenants Association
and the
Battery Park City Authority
Invite all Gateway Residents to a Virtual Informational Forum
LEARN HOW GATEWAY WILL BE AFFECTED
BY THE BPC NORTH/WEST RESILIENCY PROJECT
CLOSEST TO GATEWAY.
THE AREA INCLUDES
ESPLANADE PLAZA, KOWSKY PLAZA & NORTH COVE MARINA
WEDNESDAY, MAY 24TH, 6:30 PM Via Zoom
BPCA and the North/West Project’s designers will describe the Project and what it means for the areas nearest to Gateway.
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/82467857626?pwd=Wis3RW9Pd0JoWE93N3FBOGVBYUNodz09
Meeting ID: 824 6785 7626
Passcode: 384960
One tap mobile
+16469313860,,82467857626#,,,,*384960# US +19292056099,,82467857626#,,,,*384960# US (New York)
This is an opportunity for Gateway residents to learn how
this Project will affect us.
It will also provide an opportunity for residents to share concerns and comments on the Project with the BPCA and the Project’s designers.
Construction on the North/West Project could begin as early as 2024 and is expected to be completed by 2027.
GPTA Statement Regarding Planned Essential Workers Monument
Dear Mr. Tsunis,
We write on behalf of the over 3,000 residents of Gateway Plaza regarding the siting of the proposed Essential Workers Monument.
First, we want to thank you for listening to the BPC residents’ concerns regarding the original Rockefeller Park site, and shifting the proposed site out of Rockefeller Park. We also thank you for your general pledge to engage with BPC residents regarding BPC land use issues going forward.
We won’t add to comments that we know you’ve received regarding the appropriateness of completing a Monument on a short timeframe and on the appropriateness more generally of adding yet another memorial to BPC. We are in general agreement with comments made by CB1 and the northern BPC residents association on those subjects.
We wish to focus our comments on one of the two alternative sites that you announced last week: the Esplanade Plaza. In many ways, Esplanade Plaza is the southern BPC analog to the Rockefeller Park site that you quite correctly eliminated two weeks ago. We urge you to reject Esplanade Plaza as a potential Monument site.
Esplanade Plaza is the public square of BPC. It is at once recreational, social and community-building. There is no other site like it in BPC. In the words of BPCA’s own website, “Esplanade Plaza features plantings, seating, volleyball court, with sweeping views of the Statue of Liberty and lower New York Harbor. Often a place of local gathering, the plaza also plays host to numerous community dances performed as part of BPCA’s free outdoor programming.”
Although often referred to in short-hand as “the volleyball court,” Esplanade Plaza is much more than that, and finding another location for a volleyball court somewhere in BPC would not replace what would be lost if Esplanade Plaza were chosen as a Monument site.
Esplanade Plaza is a gathering spot for residents, office workers and visitors alike. Examples of popular BPC Parks-sponsored events held there include folk and swing dancing, tai chi, and concerts. Community groups and NYC non-profit groups use the space from May into October for events such as charity run-walk events, boating-related events, and the BPC Dogs Halloween costume parade and costume judging, It has been the home for many years of the BPC Block Party, which will resume again in 2022, after the pandemic. In winter, the Plaza is one of the largest snow-play-areas in Lower Manhattan when most of the lawns in BPC are closed.
Even the volleyball use is not just volleyball. It is an occasion for residents, office workers and visitors to come together in their enjoyment of the welcoming spirit of BPC and to savor the magnificent waterfront views while having fun with a sport that can be enjoyed simultaneously by people having a wide range of skill levels and mix of ages.
Volleyball is not the only play that takes place in Esplanade Plaza. The Plaza is overlooked by the Kowsky Plaza children’s playground, and children’s play often spills out to Esplanade Plaza. Children use Esplanade Plaza for games of catch, tag and just to run around; many BPC children learned to ride their bikes there.
An Esplanade Plaza site for the Monument would also entail significant construction disruption issues. As you know, the Plaza itself has a history of subsidence and sink holes that would likely be worsened by a project that would entail tearing up the existing Plaza and installation of 19 planter containers sufficient to hold large maple trees. Running a gas line to support an eternal flame would present health, safety and environmental issues that would need resolution. Completing such a project by Labor Day would likely require disruptive day-and-night construction for the remaining days of summer, right next to the largest residential complex in Lower Manhattan.
Finally, Esplanade Plaza is not a space that is conducive to solemn contemplation typical of memorial usage. The adjacent play area will mean the Monument would be in nearly constant earshot of loud children’s play and the nearby K-9 Sirius Dog Park. To the north, the active North Cove Marina casts a festive atmosphere for six months a year over Esplanade Plaza. The area is heavily trafficked by pedestrians and bike riders year round. To the extent that having one memorial next to another detracts from each, Esplanade Plaza would suffer from this problem, as it is nearly adjacent to the Police Memorial.
In closing, we thank you again for your decision to eliminate Rockefeller Park as a potential Essential Work Monument site. We urge you to do the same for Esplanade Plaza. The Plaza is a place of joy; please don’t convert it to a place of sadness and mourning.
Respectfully,
Rosalie Joseph, Honey Berk, Pat Gray
Robin Forst, Sarah Cassell, Howard Grossman
Jeff Galloway, Audrey Comisky, Steve Kessler
Karelene Wiese, Denise Ector
Bruce Katz, Larry Emert
Board of Directors of the Gateway Plaza Tenants Association
cc: Governor Andrew Cuomo
Congressman Jerrold Nadler
Senator Brian Kavanagh
Assemblymember Yuh-Line Niou
Assemblymember Deborah Glick
Manhattan Borough President Gale Brewer
Councilmember Margaret Chin
Manhattan Community Board 1 Chair Tammy Melzer
GPTA Annual Meeting
Thursday, March 18th, 2021, 7 PM
Via Zoom. See Link Below
The meeting will be open to all Gateway Residents
- Updates by the GPTA Board
- Introduction of our Elected Representatives
- Community Discussion Q and A. Please submit questions prior to the meeting at gatewayplazata@gmail.com. Questions can be raised at meeting as time permits.
- Nominations and Elections of Board Members. If you are interested in running for the GPTA board but have not sent in your name and bio, we will also accept nominations at the meeting.
VOTING
Only tenants who are current paid GPTA members may vote. Please note that dues are payable on the calendar basis so the 2021 dues are payable now.
TO JOIN or RENEW
Membership in GPTA is $25 per household. Go to http://www.gpta.org/join
We hope to see you there!
Rosalie Joseph, Robin Forst, Bruce Katz, Jeff Galloway, Karlene Wiese, Audrey Comisky, Denise Harris-Ector, Honey Berk, Howard Grossman, Larry Emert, Pat Gray, Sarah Cassell, Steve Kessler
ZOOM INFO
Time: Mar 18, 2021 07:00 PM Eastern Time (US and Canada)
Join Zoom Meeting
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/83425565553
Meeting ID: 834 2556 5553
One tap mobile
+19294362866,,83425565553# US (New York)
+13126266799,,83425565553# US (Chicago)